All
Search
Images
Videos
Shorts
Maps
News
More
Shopping
Flights
Travel
Notebook
Report an inappropriate content
Please select one of the options below.
Not Relevant
Offensive
Adult
Child Sexual Abuse
Top suggestions for Music Visualization Software
Free Music
Visuals
Music
Visualizer
Free Music Visualization
Downloads
Visualizer Software
Free Download
Desktop Music
Visualizer
Best Music
Visualizer
Music
Visualizer Software
Winamp
Visualizations
Free Online
Music Visualizer
Windows Music
Visualizer
3D Music
Visualizer
Music
Visualizer Generator
Cool Music
Visualizer
Length
All
Short (less than 5 minutes)
Medium (5-20 minutes)
Long (more than 20 minutes)
Date
All
Past 24 hours
Past week
Past month
Past year
Resolution
All
Lower than 360p
360p or higher
480p or higher
720p or higher
1080p or higher
Source
All
Dailymotion
Vimeo
Metacafe
Hulu
VEVO
Myspace
MTV
CBS
Fox
CNN
MSN
Price
All
Free
Paid
Clear filters
SafeSearch:
Moderate
Strict
Moderate (default)
Off
Filter
Free Music
Visuals
Music
Visualizer
Free Music Visualization
Downloads
Visualizer Software
Free Download
Desktop Music
Visualizer
Best Music
Visualizer
Music
Visualizer Software
Winamp
Visualizations
Free Online
Music Visualizer
Windows Music
Visualizer
3D Music
Visualizer
Music
Visualizer Generator
Cool Music
Visualizer
Shop music visualization software
Sponsored
$9.99
Avid Pro Tools Artist - Monthly Subscription (Automatic Renewal) Pro Tools Artist Software With Standard Support And Artist AAX Plug-In Bundle -
Sweetwater
$9.99
Avid Pro Tools Artist - Monthly Subscription (Automatic Renewal) Pro Tools Artist Software With Standard Support And Artist AAX Plug-In Bundle -
Sweetwater
$99.00
Celemony Melodyne 5 Essential Monophonic Pitch And Time Shifting Software Monophonic Pitch And Time Shifting Software With Pitched Algorithms, Pitch
Sweetwater
24
$99.00
Celemony Melodyne 5 Essential Monophonic Pitch And Time Shifting Software Monophonic Pitch And Time Shifting Software With Pitched Algorithms, Pitch
Sweetwater
24
$99.00
Image Line FL Studio Fruity Edition - Boxed MIDI Music Production Software With Virtual Instruments And Plug-In Processors, And Support For VST And
Sweetwater
474
$99.00
Image Line FL Studio Fruity Edition - Boxed MIDI Music Production Software With Virtual Instruments And Plug-In Processors, And Support For VST And
Sweetwater
474
$149.00
Celemony Melodyne 5 Studio - Upgrade From Melodyne Studio 3 Multitrack Pitch And Time Shifting Software With Polyphonic Capability, Melodic And
Sweetwater
$149.00
Celemony Melodyne 5 Studio - Upgrade From Melodyne Studio 3 Multitrack Pitch And Time Shifting Software With Polyphonic Capability, Melodic And
Sweetwater
$34.99
Avid Pro Tools Studio - Monthly Subscription (Automatic Renewal) Pro Tools Studio Software With Standard Support, Surround/Dolby Atmos/Ambisonics
Sweetwater
13
$34.99
Avid Pro Tools Studio - Monthly Subscription (Automatic Renewal) Pro Tools Studio Software With Standard Support, Surround/Dolby Atmos/Ambisonics
Sweetwater
13
$199.00
Avid Pro Tools Artist - Perpetual License Pro Tools Artist Software With Standard Support And Artist AAX Plug-In Bundle - Macos/Windows
Sweetwater
$199.00
Avid Pro Tools Artist - Perpetual License Pro Tools Artist Software With Standard Support And Artist AAX Plug-In Bundle - Macos/Windows
Sweetwater
$149.00
Avid Sibelius Artist Perpetual License With 1 Year Of Updates + Support Plan Streamlined Professional Notation Software - Macos/Windows
Sweetwater
$149.00
Avid Sibelius Artist Perpetual License With 1 Year Of Updates + Support Plan Streamlined Professional Notation Software - Macos/Windows
Sweetwater
$269.00
Image Line FL Studio Signature Edition Sequencing And Music Production Software With Audio Recording, Virtual Instruments, Plug-In Processors, And
Sweetwater
16
$269.00
Image Line FL Studio Signature Edition Sequencing And Music Production Software With Audio Recording, Virtual Instruments, Plug-In Processors, And
Sweetwater
16
$49.99
Magix Acid Music Studio 11 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$49.99
Magix Acid Music Studio 11 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$459.00
Image Line FL Studio Producer Edition With UVI Falcon 3.1 Hybrid Synthesizer Software Sequencing And Music Production Software With Audio Recording,
Sweetwater
$459.00
Image Line FL Studio Producer Edition With UVI Falcon 3.1 Hybrid Synthesizer Software Sequencing And Music Production Software With Audio Recording,
Sweetwater
$49.99
MAGIX ACID Music Studio 11 For Windows 64-Bit Loop-Based DAW With 2,500+ Acidized Loops, 8 Virtual Instruments, And 6 Effects - Windows
Sweetwater
5
$49.99
MAGIX ACID Music Studio 11 For Windows 64-Bit Loop-Based DAW With 2,500+ Acidized Loops, 8 Virtual Instruments, And 6 Effects - Windows
Sweetwater
5
$149.00
Celemony Melodyne 5 Editor Upgrade From Melodyne 4 Or 5 Assistant Pitch And Time Shifting Software With Polyphonic Capability, Melodic And
Sweetwater
5
$149.00
Celemony Melodyne 5 Editor Upgrade From Melodyne 4 Or 5 Assistant Pitch And Time Shifting Software With Polyphonic Capability, Melodic And
Sweetwater
5
$59.99
Magix Music Maker Premium 2026 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$59.99
Magix Music Maker Premium 2026 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$14.99
Magix Acid Music Studio 9 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$14.99
Magix Acid Music Studio 9 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$39.00
Magix Music Maker Premium 2023 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$39.00
Magix Music Maker Premium 2023 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$199.99
Fender Studio Pro DAW Software - Perpetual License DAW Software With Unlimited Tracks, Dolby Atmos Support, Video Editing, Mastering Tools, And
Sweetwater
1
$199.99
Fender Studio Pro DAW Software - Perpetual License DAW Software With Unlimited Tracks, Dolby Atmos Support, Video Editing, Mastering Tools, And
Sweetwater
1
$199.00
NUGEN Audio Visualizer Audio Analysis Suite Graphical Display And Analysis Plug-In - Standalone, AAX Native, Audiosuite, AU, VST3
Sweetwater
$199.00
NUGEN Audio Visualizer Audio Analysis Suite Graphical Display And Analysis Plug-In - Standalone, AAX Native, Audiosuite, AU, VST3
Sweetwater
$149.00
Acoustica Mixcraft 10.5 Pro Studio DAW Software With Unlimited Tracks, Integrated Online Store, Natively Integrated Melodyne, Audio To MIDI
Sweetwater
8
$149.00
Acoustica Mixcraft 10.5 Pro Studio DAW Software With Unlimited Tracks, Integrated Online Store, Natively Integrated Melodyne, Audio To MIDI
Sweetwater
8
$299.00
NUGEN Audio Halo Vision Analysis Visual Analysis Tool For Immersive Mixes - AAX Native, AU, VST3
Sweetwater
$299.00
NUGEN Audio Halo Vision Analysis Visual Analysis Tool For Immersive Mixes - AAX Native, AU, VST3
Sweetwater
$199.00
Pro Tools Artist Perpetual License - AVID - Music Audio Software - NEW
eBay
Free shipping
$199.00
Pro Tools Artist Perpetual License - AVID - Music Audio Software - NEW
eBay
Free shipping
$69.00
Avid Pro Tools Artist - Perpetual Upgrade Pro Tools Artist Software With Standard Support And Artist AAX Plug-In Bundle - Macos/Windows
Sweetwater
$69.00
Avid Pro Tools Artist - Perpetual Upgrade Pro Tools Artist Software With Standard Support And Artist AAX Plug-In Bundle - Macos/Windows
Sweetwater
$549.00
Tracktion Waveform Pro 12 Upgrade From Waveform Pro 11 W/ Studio Bundle, Download
Adorama Camera
$549.00
Tracktion Waveform Pro 12 Upgrade From Waveform Pro 11 W/ Studio Bundle, Download
Adorama Camera
$999.00
Tracktion Waveform Pro 12 Music Production Software Everything Bundle, Download
Adorama Camera
$999.00
Tracktion Waveform Pro 12 Music Production Software Everything Bundle, Download
Adorama Camera
$29.99
ACID Music Studio 10 Download | Legit Retailer | Softwarecw
SoftwareCW
$29.99
ACID Music Studio 10 Download | Legit Retailer | Softwarecw
SoftwareCW
videoproc.com
Top 13 Best Music Visualizers in Realtime and Recordable
What are the best real-time music visualizers? Besides the online free Renderforest website, HTML5 Spotify visualizers, free spectrum tool, and audio visualizer software /plug-ins are also good options.
Nov 28, 2024
Music Visualization Examples
1:54
Abstract Music Visualizer (Flexible Duration (up to 10 min.)) | Renderforest
renderforest.com
10 views
2 weeks ago
Music Visualization Players for Instagram Story
envato.com
Nov 29, 2023
18:00
The beauty of data visualization
TED
David McCandless
4M views
Aug 23, 2010
Top videos
Audio Reactive Music Visualizer
envato.com
Jul 30, 2020
1:01
The World's Ultimate Music Visualizer! An immersive visual experience driven by your music | Luminant Music
Facebook
Luminant Music
108.2K views
May 8, 2019
Building a Generative AI Music Visualizer with JavaScript and React
git.ir
Oct 12, 2024
How to Create Music Visualization
Music Visualizer Online | Specterr Video Maker
specterr.com
Jul 22, 2020
Free music video maker to create music videos online | Canva
canva.com
Mar 8, 2022
0:31
Free Music Visualizer Online | Renderforest
renderforest.com
20 views
May 5, 2017
Audio Reactive Music Visualizer
Jul 30, 2020
envato.com
1:01
The World's Ultimate Music Visualizer! An immersive visual ex
…
108.2K views
May 8, 2019
Facebook
Luminant Music
Building a Generative AI Music Visualizer with JavaScript and React
Oct 12, 2024
git.ir
0:31
Free Music Visualizer Online | Renderforest
20 views
May 5, 2017
renderforest.com
Bass Drops Music Visualizer (Flexible Duration) | Renderforest
1 week ago
renderforest.com
Kinetic Objects Music Visualizer (Widescreen Version) | Renderforest
1 week ago
renderforest.com
The 7 best music visualizers in 2024
May 28, 2024
renderforest.com
Top 5 Best Music (Audio) Visualizers in 2021 - Free and Paid
Jun 3, 2021
veed.io
0:57
Music Visualizer - 3D audio spectrum visualizer made with Uni
…
352.6K views
Dec 18, 2017
YouTube
Tim Michels
HUD Music Visualizer
Nov 5, 2016
videohive.net
Cyber Music Visualizer (Flexible Duration (up to 10 min.)) | Renderf
…
1 month ago
renderforest.com
Create a Music Visualizer
Mar 30, 2021
devpost.com
Audio spectrum music visualizer videopad video editor
Nov 28, 2023
weebly.com
Audio Spectrum Music Visualizer
4 views
Feb 7, 2024
envato.com
Music Visualizer Online - Just Drag and Drop Your Audio
May 25, 2018
videobolt.net
Music Visualizer for Live Performances
46.5K views
Oct 2, 2020
instructables.com
Music Visualizer
Dec 12, 2014
amazon.com.au
Top 6 Best Free Music Visualizers - MiniTool MovieMaker
Mar 24, 2020
minitool.com
10 Best FREE Music Visualiser Apps for iPhone and Android[2025]
10 months ago
wondershare.com
Online Music Visualizer - Create Free Videos with Waves
Jun 19, 2024
vokal.co
Music Visualizer Online | Specterr Video Maker
Jul 22, 2020
specterr.com
3:20
The Best Software for Concert Visuals
105.4K views
Apr 17, 2020
YouTube
Sean Bowes
Turntable Music Visualizer
Oct 1, 2020
videohive.net
0:49
Falling Loop Music Visualizer | How to Create a Music Visualization Te
…
3.4K views
Apr 29, 2022
YouTube
Renderforest
Beach Music and Podcast Visualizer 3D
Jul 8, 2021
videohive.net
Alternative Music Visualizer (Flexible Duration (up to 10 min.))
…
3 weeks ago
renderforest.com
4:51
Spectrolizer - Music Player & Visualizer (Short Demo)
196.5K views
Jun 3, 2022
YouTube
Spectrolizer
22:21
Making your music visualizer with AI: Five techniques to master
22.9K views
Aug 21, 2024
YouTube
neural frames
7 Best Free Music Visualization Apps for iPhone - Applavia
7 views
Aug 19, 2021
applavia.com
See more videos
More like this
Shop music visualization software
Sponsored
$149.00
Celemony Melodyne 5 Editor Upgrade From Melodyne 4 Or 5 Assistant Pitch And Time Shifting Software With Polyphonic Capability, Melodic And
Sweetwater
5
$149.00
Celemony Melodyne 5 Editor Upgrade From Melodyne 4 Or 5 Assistant Pitch And Time Shifting Software With Polyphonic Capability, Melodic And
Sweetwater
$59.99
Magix Music Maker Premium 2026 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$59.99
Magix Music Maker Premium 2026 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$14.99
Magix Acid Music Studio 9 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$14.99
Magix Acid Music Studio 9 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$39.00
Magix Music Maker Premium 2023 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$39.00
Magix Music Maker Premium 2023 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$199.99
Fender Studio Pro DAW Software - Perpetual License DAW Software With Unlimited Tracks, Dolby Atmos Support, Video Editing, Mastering Tools, And
Sweetwater
1
$199.99
Fender Studio Pro DAW Software - Perpetual License DAW Software With Unlimited Tracks, Dolby Atmos Support, Video Editing, Mastering Tools, And
Sweetwater
$199.00
NUGEN Audio Visualizer Audio Analysis Suite Graphical Display And Analysis Plug-In - Standalone, AAX Native, Audiosuite, AU, VST3
Sweetwater
$199.00
NUGEN Audio Visualizer Audio Analysis Suite Graphical Display And Analysis Plug-In - Standalone, AAX Native, Audiosuite, AU, VST3
Sweetwater
$149.00
Acoustica Mixcraft 10.5 Pro Studio DAW Software With Unlimited Tracks, Integrated Online Store, Natively Integrated Melodyne, Audio To MIDI
Sweetwater
8
$149.00
Acoustica Mixcraft 10.5 Pro Studio DAW Software With Unlimited Tracks, Integrated Online Store, Natively Integrated Melodyne, Audio To MIDI
Sweetwater
$299.00
NUGEN Audio Halo Vision Analysis Visual Analysis Tool For Immersive Mixes - AAX Native, AU, VST3
Sweetwater
$299.00
NUGEN Audio Halo Vision Analysis Visual Analysis Tool For Immersive Mixes - AAX Native, AU, VST3
Sweetwater
$199.00
Pro Tools Artist Perpetual License - AVID - Music Audio Software - NEW
eBay
Free shipping
$199.00
Pro Tools Artist Perpetual License - AVID - Music Audio Software - NEW
eBay
$69.00
Avid Pro Tools Artist - Perpetual Upgrade Pro Tools Artist Software With Standard Support And Artist AAX Plug-In Bundle - Macos/Windows
Sweetwater
$69.00
Avid Pro Tools Artist - Perpetual Upgrade Pro Tools Artist Software With Standard Support And Artist AAX Plug-In Bundle - Macos/Windows
Sweetwater
$549.00
Tracktion Waveform Pro 12 Upgrade From Waveform Pro 11 W/ Studio Bundle, Download
Adorama Camera
$549.00
Tracktion Waveform Pro 12 Upgrade From Waveform Pro 11 W/ Studio Bundle, Download
Adorama Camera
$999.00
Tracktion Waveform Pro 12 Music Production Software Everything Bundle, Download
Adorama Camera
$999.00
Tracktion Waveform Pro 12 Music Production Software Everything Bundle, Download
Adorama Camera
$29.99
ACID Music Studio 10 Download | Legit Retailer | Softwarecw
SoftwareCW
$29.99
ACID Music Studio 10 Download | Legit Retailer | Softwarecw
SoftwareCW
$449.00
Image Line FL Studio All Plug-Ins Edition Sequencing And Music Production Software With Audio Recording, Virtual Instruments, Complete Plug-In
Sweetwater
$449.00
Image Line FL Studio All Plug-Ins Edition Sequencing And Music Production Software With Audio Recording, Virtual Instruments, Complete Plug-In
Sweetwater
$34.99
Waves Codex Wavetable Synthesizer Software Virtual Instruments Virtual Polyphonic Wavetable Synthesizer Plug-In With 2 Oscillators,
Sweetwater
$34.99
Waves Codex Wavetable Synthesizer Software Virtual Instruments Virtual Polyphonic Wavetable Synthesizer Plug-In With 2 Oscillators,
Sweetwater
$199.00
Avid Pro Tools Studio Perpetual License Upgrade (Updates And Support For 1 Year) DAW Software With Standard Support, Surround/Dolby Atmos/Ambisonics
Sweetwater
34
$199.00
Avid Pro Tools Studio Perpetual License Upgrade (Updates And Support For 1 Year) DAW Software With Standard Support, Surround/Dolby Atmos/Ambisonics
Sweetwater
$599.00
Avid Pro Tools Studio Music Production Software Perpetual License
zZounds
$599.00
Avid Pro Tools Studio Music Production Software Perpetual License
zZounds
$299.00
Tracktion Waveform Pro 12 Software With Recommended Content Bundle, Download
Adorama Camera
$299.00
Tracktion Waveform Pro 12 Software With Recommended Content Bundle, Download
Adorama Camera
Shop music visualization software
Sponsored
$9.99
Avid Pro Tools Artist - Monthly Subscription (Automatic Renewal) Pro Tools Artist Software With Standard Support And Artist AAX Plug-In Bundle -
Sweetwater
$9.99
Avid Pro Tools Artist - Monthly Subscription (Automatic Renewal) Pro Tools Artist Software With Standard Support And Artist AAX Plug-In Bundle -
Sweetwater
$99.00
Celemony Melodyne 5 Essential Monophonic Pitch And Time Shifting Software Monophonic Pitch And Time Shifting Software With Pitched Algorithms, Pitch
Sweetwater
24
$99.00
Celemony Melodyne 5 Essential Monophonic Pitch And Time Shifting Software Monophonic Pitch And Time Shifting Software With Pitched Algorithms, Pitch
Sweetwater
24
$99.00
Image Line FL Studio Fruity Edition - Boxed MIDI Music Production Software With Virtual Instruments And Plug-In Processors, And Support For VST And
Sweetwater
474
$99.00
Image Line FL Studio Fruity Edition - Boxed MIDI Music Production Software With Virtual Instruments And Plug-In Processors, And Support For VST And
Sweetwater
474
$149.00
Celemony Melodyne 5 Studio - Upgrade From Melodyne Studio 3 Multitrack Pitch And Time Shifting Software With Polyphonic Capability, Melodic And
Sweetwater
$149.00
Celemony Melodyne 5 Studio - Upgrade From Melodyne Studio 3 Multitrack Pitch And Time Shifting Software With Polyphonic Capability, Melodic And
Sweetwater
$34.99
Avid Pro Tools Studio - Monthly Subscription (Automatic Renewal) Pro Tools Studio Software With Standard Support, Surround/Dolby Atmos/Ambisonics
Sweetwater
13
$34.99
Avid Pro Tools Studio - Monthly Subscription (Automatic Renewal) Pro Tools Studio Software With Standard Support, Surround/Dolby Atmos/Ambisonics
Sweetwater
13
$199.00
Avid Pro Tools Artist - Perpetual License Pro Tools Artist Software With Standard Support And Artist AAX Plug-In Bundle - Macos/Windows
Sweetwater
$199.00
Avid Pro Tools Artist - Perpetual License Pro Tools Artist Software With Standard Support And Artist AAX Plug-In Bundle - Macos/Windows
Sweetwater
$149.00
Avid Sibelius Artist Perpetual License With 1 Year Of Updates + Support Plan Streamlined Professional Notation Software - Macos/Windows
Sweetwater
$149.00
Avid Sibelius Artist Perpetual License With 1 Year Of Updates + Support Plan Streamlined Professional Notation Software - Macos/Windows
Sweetwater
$269.00
Image Line FL Studio Signature Edition Sequencing And Music Production Software With Audio Recording, Virtual Instruments, Plug-In Processors, And
Sweetwater
16
$269.00
Image Line FL Studio Signature Edition Sequencing And Music Production Software With Audio Recording, Virtual Instruments, Plug-In Processors, And
Sweetwater
16
$49.99
Magix Acid Music Studio 11 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$49.99
Magix Acid Music Studio 11 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$459.00
Image Line FL Studio Producer Edition With UVI Falcon 3.1 Hybrid Synthesizer Software Sequencing And Music Production Software With Audio Recording,
Sweetwater
$459.00
Image Line FL Studio Producer Edition With UVI Falcon 3.1 Hybrid Synthesizer Software Sequencing And Music Production Software With Audio Recording,
Sweetwater
$49.99
MAGIX ACID Music Studio 11 For Windows 64-Bit Loop-Based DAW With 2,500+ Acidized Loops, 8 Virtual Instruments, And 6 Effects - Windows
Sweetwater
5
$49.99
MAGIX ACID Music Studio 11 For Windows 64-Bit Loop-Based DAW With 2,500+ Acidized Loops, 8 Virtual Instruments, And 6 Effects - Windows
Sweetwater
5
$149.00
Celemony Melodyne 5 Editor Upgrade From Melodyne 4 Or 5 Assistant Pitch And Time Shifting Software With Polyphonic Capability, Melodic And
Sweetwater
5
$149.00
Celemony Melodyne 5 Editor Upgrade From Melodyne 4 Or 5 Assistant Pitch And Time Shifting Software With Polyphonic Capability, Melodic And
Sweetwater
5
$59.99
Magix Music Maker Premium 2026 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$59.99
Magix Music Maker Premium 2026 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$14.99
Magix Acid Music Studio 9 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$14.99
Magix Acid Music Studio 9 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$39.00
Magix Music Maker Premium 2023 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$39.00
Magix Music Maker Premium 2023 - Instant Download For Windows
SoftwareCW
$199.99
Fender Studio Pro DAW Software - Perpetual License DAW Software With Unlimited Tracks, Dolby Atmos Support, Video Editing, Mastering Tools, And
Sweetwater
1
$199.99
Fender Studio Pro DAW Software - Perpetual License DAW Software With Unlimited Tracks, Dolby Atmos Support, Video Editing, Mastering Tools, And
Sweetwater
1
$199.00
NUGEN Audio Visualizer Audio Analysis Suite Graphical Display And Analysis Plug-In - Standalone, AAX Native, Audiosuite, AU, VST3
Sweetwater
$199.00
NUGEN Audio Visualizer Audio Analysis Suite Graphical Display And Analysis Plug-In - Standalone, AAX Native, Audiosuite, AU, VST3
Sweetwater
$149.00
Acoustica Mixcraft 10.5 Pro Studio DAW Software With Unlimited Tracks, Integrated Online Store, Natively Integrated Melodyne, Audio To MIDI
Sweetwater
8
$149.00
Acoustica Mixcraft 10.5 Pro Studio DAW Software With Unlimited Tracks, Integrated Online Store, Natively Integrated Melodyne, Audio To MIDI
Sweetwater
8
Music Visualizer | Free Download | Audio Visualizer Filmora
View Plans
https://filmora.wondershare.net
Sponsored
Create eye-catching music videos with Filmora's Audio visualizer. Try it …
Feedback
Feedback